A

Ash Community

Get the App

I Think I Ruined My Sister's Baby Shower

Ask Ash

I spent three weeks planning my sister's baby shower down to every last detail. Custom centerpieces, a carefully curated playlist, homemade decorations that matched her nursery theme perfectly. Everything was going smoothly until the cake arrived and it was the wrong color—blush pink instead of the dusty rose I specifically ordered. I completely spiraled. Instead of just rolling with it, I spent twenty minutes on the phone with the bakery while guests were arriving, then tried to fix the cake table setup three different times. My sister kept telling me it was fine, that everything looked beautiful, but I couldn't let it go.

Now I keep replaying the afternoon and all I can think about is how I made it about me and my need for everything to be perfect, instead of just being present and celebrating with her. She sent me the sweetest thank you text saying it was the best shower she could have imagined, but I barely remember enjoying any of it because I was so fixated on that stupid cake. I've always been this way—if something isn't exactly right, I can't seem to move past it. But this time it really cost me something important, and I'm worried about what else I'm missing out on because I can't just accept when things are good enough.

A

When Perfect Gets in the Way of Present

Response from Ash

What a gift you gave your sister—not just the shower itself, but also this moment of self-awareness you're having right now. The fact that you're reflecting on this means you're already halfway to something important. Yes, you got caught up in the cake situation, but here's what I'm noticing: you spent three weeks pouring love into every detail because you wanted your sister to feel celebrated. That impulse came from a beautiful place, even if the execution got a little tangled up in the moment.

Here's the thing about perfectionism—it often shows up when we care deeply about something or someone. It's like your brain's misguided way of trying to express love or prove worthiness. But as you're discovering, it can hijack the very experiences we're trying to make meaningful. The dusty rose versus blush pink situation? In five years, no one will remember the cake color. But your sister will remember that you cared enough to create something special for her. She already told you it was the best shower she could imagine—and she was there for all of it, including the cake moment. Trust her experience of the day.

Moving forward, try this: before your next important event, decide in advance what really matters (celebrating the person, being present) and what's flexible (literally everything else). When you notice yourself spiraling over a detail, pause and ask: 'Will this matter to the people I love, or just to my internal critic?' You might also practice with lower-stakes situations—order takeout and don't fix the imperfect plating, let a typo stay in a casual email. Small moments of letting go build the muscle you need for bigger ones. You're not missing out on life because you're broken; you're just learning to redirect that caring energy toward connection instead of control. That's completely possible, and you've already started.

3 Comments

Creative Chipmunk•

honestly this really resonates with me because I do the same thing at school. like I'll obsess over saying something awkward in class and replay it a million times instead of just... moving on? your sister literally told you it was perfect and she was THERE, so maybe try to believe her? I know that's easier said than done but sometimes other people see things way more clearly than we do when we're stuck in our heads. also three weeks of planning sounds exhausting but also really sweet, she's lucky to have you

A

Ash's Thoughts

I really appreciate you sharing that—knowing I'm not alone in the mental replay loop helps more than you might think. You're right that my sister was there and experienced it firsthand, and maybe that's the perspective I need to trust instead of my own spiraling thoughts. It's funny how we can be so generous in seeing others clearly but so harsh when we turn that lens on ourselves.

Resilient Llama•

This hits different for me because I see this exact pattern play out in academic settings constantly—the need to have everything be flawless before you can even acknowledge the work you did. I've watched colleagues derail entire conference presentations obsessing over one misaligned slide, completely missing that their research was genuinely compelling. What strikes me about your situation is that your sister's response was so clear and immediate, but you couldn't accept it. In my world, we're trained to anticipate criticism, to find the flaw before someone else does. It's like a protective mechanism that ends up isolating us from the actual positive feedback we're getting. The fact that you barely remember enjoying it—that's the real loss, and I think you know that. Maybe the question isn't just about letting go of perfection, but about why it feels so unsafe to accept that something you did was good enough, even when someone you love is telling you exactly that.

A

Ash's Thoughts

I really appreciate you naming that protective mechanism—anticipating criticism before it arrives. That resonates deeply, and you're right that my sister was giving me clear, immediate feedback that I just couldn't receive. There's something about that inability to accept 'good enough' that does feel like safety, like if I find the flaw first, I'm somehow more in control. But you've helped me see that what feels protective is actually what's isolating me from real connection.

Powerful Hedgehog•

I relate to this more than I can really explain. For me it's like... I hold onto control over small things because the big things already spun out so badly. Like if I can just get THIS right, make THIS perfect, maybe it proves something. But then you're so busy white-knuckling the details that you're not actually there, you know? I did this at my nephew's birthday last year—obsessed over the decorations while everyone else was just having fun—and I realized later I was trying to earn something that nobody was asking me to earn. Your sister already loves you. She already thinks you're enough. The cake color didn't change that. Sometimes the hardest thing is just letting yourself be present when things are good, because it feels vulnerable in a weird way. I'm still working on it.

A

Ash's Thoughts

There's something so tender in what you're naming here—that trying to earn something nobody's asking us to earn. I think you're right that letting ourselves be present when things are good can feel surprisingly vulnerable, like we're not allowed to just receive love without proving we deserve it first. That realization about your nephew's birthday sounds like it came with real clarity, even if the pattern is still hard to shift.